Five myths (and truths) about hay fever

  13 May 2019    Read: 1989
  Five   myths   (and truths) about hay fever

Many of us are afflicted by the sniffles and itchiness of hay fever. Should we pray for rain? Do pollen levels fall at night? 

Noses are running, eyes are streaming, throats are itching and people are sneezing. As the hay fever season gets underway, affecting between 10% and 30% of people, we sifted through the evidence to work out what’s really true about this irritating condition.

Hay fever has nothing to do with hay

Back in the early 19th Century it was assumed that freshly cut hay was causing the problem, hence the name hay fever. Then a British doctor called James Bostock, who found himself suffering these curious symptoms every summer, correctly identified that exposure to hay was not the cause. He found relief from his hay fever by heading to the seaside, but incorrectly concluded that his symptoms was caused by some kind of recurring disease made worse by hot summers. He dubbed it “summer catarrh”.

The connection with pollen was made in 1859 by a British scientist called Charles Blackley, who is said to have sneezed when he sniffed a bouquet of bluegrass. He not only worked out that pollen was to blame, but that the lighter pollen produced by grasses and trees, which became airborne more easily, was more likely to induce symptoms. Again he only got it partly right. The role of the immune system in allergic reactions wasn’t yet understood, leaving him to assume that the unpleasant symptoms were caused by toxins in the pollen.

Today we know that when some individuals encounter pollen of certain kinds, their immune system overreacts, treating the pollen as it might a virus. This then triggers the body to respond with all the familiar hay fever symptoms.

VERDICT: True

As much as 30% of the population is affected by hayfever as the pollen counts rise (Credit: Getty Images)


Hay fever is something you grow out of

Typically we might assume that hay fever starts when you’re a child and gradually wears off as you get older. The good news is that half of people do find their symptoms ease a bit with age, and for a lucky 20% they disappear completely. A Swedish study found that it was most likely to disappear when people were in their 50s. But for the remainder the symptoms continue to recur every year when the pollen season starts.

It can also happen the other way around. There are people who never experienced hay fever as children or teenagers who find they’re struck down with symptoms for the first time in their 30s and 40s. Unfortunately, cases of hay fever do seem on the rise in many places.

VERDICT: True, but only if you’re lucky

Hay fever is not as bad after it’s rained because the water washes away the pollen

Some hay fever sufferers pray for rain in the hope that the damp conditions will stop pollen from spreading through the air and into their eyes and noses. Light-to-moderate rainfall does help, but heavy rain can have the opposite effect. When health insurance data was analysed in South Korea and compared with weather conditions on each day, visits to outpatients for allergic rhinitis rose after heavy rain or typhoons.

The crucial cut-off point appears to be 10cm (4in) of rainfall. When researchers in the US analysed 14 years of meteorological and pollen count data, they found that levels of pollen fell after less than 10cm of rain, but rose if there was more than 10cm. Heavy rain seems to whip more pollen up into the air, especially if it’s windy as well as rainy.

VERDICT: It depends on the amount of rain

Does the pollen count really go down after there's been a downpour? (Credit: Getty Images)

Hay fever is worse during the day

If you suffer from hay fever the standard advice is to stay indoors during the day when the pollen levels are higher, waiting until the evening to venture out. Staying inside can help, but unfortunately it’s not quite that simple. It all depends on which kind of pollen is affecting you.

In a study with the nice title “Pollen nightmare: elevated airborne pollen levels at night” traps were set on a rooftop in Poland and the concentrations of five common types of pollen were measured day and night.

Levels of mugwort pollen were indeed lower at night than during the day, but levels of ragweed pollen were higher, while grass and alder pollen levels varied little over a 24-hour period.

As temperatures rise during the day, pollen-bearing air rises, but at night the pollen descends again, increasing the concentrations at ground level, so by dawn some people will find their hay fever has become worse. Levels at different times depend on how easily the pollen becomes airborne, how far it tends to travel and the time of day when a particular species of grass releases its pollen. Mugwort doesn’t get carried very far and levels remain low at night, while ragweed goes further afield.

So the answer to this question depends on where you live, which grasses are common nearby and which grasses you’re allergic to.

Verdict: Not necessarily

Antihistamines for hay fever make you drowsy

Antihistamines can ease some symptoms of hay fever by blocking the action of the chemical histamine, released by the body when it thinks it is under attack from the proteins in pollen. The problem is that with the older types of first-generation antihistamines, drowsiness was a common side-effect. At night time people didn’t necessarily mind since their sneezing and itchy eyes disturbed their sleep, so a little help in dozing off suited them, but during the day it’s not so good to feel sleepy.

But in the 1980s and 90s several newer, so-called second-generation antihistamines were introduced. These cannot cross the blood-brain barrier so readily, leading to fewer or sometimes no symptoms of sleepiness.

VERDICT: Yes – but only sometimes

Honey has long been thought of as a way of lessening the severity of hayfever symptoms (Credit: Getty Images)

Honey can reduce the symptoms of hay fever

A spoonful of honey has long been recommended by some, but does it actually work? Very little research has been done to find out. In a small study conducted in the US, people were given one of three substances to take: pasteurised honey, unpasteurised honey or a corn syrup artificially-flavoured to taste like honey. The people didn’t know which they had been given and were told to take a tablespoon a day alongside any usual treatment they took to ease their hay fever. Neither type of honey made a difference to the severity of their symptoms.

A small study conducted in Finland found that regular honey made only a marginal difference, but that honey with added birch pollen did seem to help. The authors caution, however, that this was only a pilot study and shouldn’t be taken as a recommendation.

VERDICT: It tastes nice, but any proof that it works is currently lacking

 

BBC


More about: hayfever